Sunday, April 15, 2012

RR 13: The Race for Height - Skyscrapers & Globalization

According to Ching in the final pages of his textbook, "the tension between the global and the national is the fundamental paradox of our age" [797]. I found this commentary to be fascinating and immediately applicable for the discussion of the skyscraper height race that both Ching and Roth delve into in the final pages of their texts. Globalization and a market driven, corporate minded world economy has directly impacted the world of architecture as each corporation and nation compete against each other for the largest and tallest skyscraper as a symbol of their power and wealth. Some of the tallest in the current race include:

http://blog.kievukraine.info/uploaded_images/5161-760392.jpg
  • The Commerzbank in Frankfurt, Germany is the tallest building in Europe at 850 feet. Notably, this building is also green-certified, including sky gardens and sheathed in aluminum. 

http://funpresident.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/jin_mao_tower_02.jpg
  • Outside of Europe, Shanghai has competed for the place of principal interchange between the East and West, and this has culminated in a height race among skyscrapers within the city. The 88-story Jin Mao Tower (above) was the first of these, developed by Skidmore, Owings & Merrell at 1380 feet.

http://www.architectmagazine.com/Images/tmp7FB6.tmp_tcm20-231931.jpg
  • The Shanghai World Financial Center (above), virtually next door to the Jin Mao Tower, was developed by Kohn Pederson Fox with 101 floors or 1614 feet.

http://tiscsvr.tbroc.gov.tw/photo/120/001/120-001832.jpg
  • Taipei 101 (above), in Taipei was designed by Taiwanese architect C.Y. Lee, at 101 stories or 1670 feet, including its spire.
http://purplefok.com/ghs_ict/ifc.jpg
  •   Two International Finance Center (above) was completed the same year as Taipei 101 in Hong Kong, also by Cesar Pelli at 1,362 feet. 
http://0.tqn.com/d/architecture/1/0/b/v/BurjDubaiFlickr.jpg
  • The current tallest building in the world is the Burj Dubai (above), in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, designed by Skidmore, Owings & Merril that reached an astounding 2723 feet. 
Of course the height wars are not over, and with increased technology from the information age and CAD, new proposals are submitted. A third skyscraper for Shanghai is scheduled to be completed 2014 that is also over 2000 feet, designed by Gensler (image below).

http://www.archpaper.com/news/articles.asp?id=3087
As the large global architecture firms compete for commissions for the greatest vertical structures, I find that this race for height is personally disheartening in its waste of materials and complete disregard for larger, non-ego driven global needs like sustainability, environmental concerns, and poverty. A tall skyscraper, while increasing name brand recognition during the moment of greatest height achieved fame, does not directly increase the overall profit gains for the company in the long run. A skyscraper in itself does not generate more income.

However, in a discussion of where the design world might be headed, I do think that these geographical landmarks are indicators that a Western centralized global economy is on the decline, while a more Eastern economy is increasing in dominance and leading the conversation of a globalized economy. I think that we will see more of an Eastern influence in the everyday design culture here in the West as time progresses. For me, this is a reminder to look beyond my current surroundings and instead to the international stage for new ideas and direction.

Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Fallingwater and Monticello

 A few weeks ago, the first year class and several iarc department professors and grad students took a field trip to Monticello and Fallingwater over a 36 hour time span. It was a whirlwind trip consisting of long hours in the bus, but was well worth the travel time to see these two monumental places. We started with Monticello on Sunday and saw Fallingwater on Monday (and were back home from PA that night!). Below is a small collection of photos from the trip.
me & tj



the winding road up to tj's house

front facade

the backside of the hizzouse

from across the expansive lawn

crops!

tulips :)

tj's wu-wu

the long winding path back downhill - i loved the purple & green combo. thanks nature!

thonet knockoffs in the cafe

tj on uva - doric column repetitional glory

the prestigious quad housing at uva - everyone has a grill, lulz

i'm really digging this side path & garden wall

uva chapel

undulating with desire

oh hello, frank

i wish my porch steps landed in a river


compression & horizontal layers in full frank glory

out of the rock

don't jump! its too shallow!

front facade across the rio

ah yes, the classic fallingwater shot (notably the site that the Kauffman's actually wanted their house built on)

and from above, with a look at the guest house. where i would live. with my pool boy. 

Project 2.2: Bedroom in Blocks




Sunday, April 8, 2012

RR12: Changes in a Chapel at Ronchamp

We are entering into the modern era of architecture in the final weeks of this class, which is classified as a radical break with past forms. There are many different explorations in how this break is classified, and with the introduction of new building materials like steel and concrete, the expression of these new ideas significantly challenges building expectations from the 20th century on.

Le Corbusier is one such architect whose use of concrete in innovative forms and a free plan challenges even the most historically conservative architectural types: the catholic church. His chapel, Notre Dame de Haut at Ronchamp was built in 1955 in the Jura Mountains of eastern France on the site of a former pilgrimage chapel that was demolished in WWII. The new chapel is sculptural in form (see below).
http://www.archdaily.com/84988/ad-classics-ronchamp-le-corbusier/
The walls and the roof are all curvilinear (see below), sculptural in form and intentionally contrasting the traditional forms of a chapel building. The curve of the walls structurally support the curve of the massive roof and additionally are acoustical components for sound to carry across the hillside when services are conducted out of doors.

http://www.archdaily.com/84988/ad-classics-ronchamp-le-corbusier/      




 The interior was designed to include:
-chapel tower
-sacristy tower
-baptistry tower
-two entrances
-one altar

But perhaps the most compelling feature of the Chapel at Ronchamp is the interior light. "Corbusier wanted the space to be meditative and reflective in purpose.  The stark white walls add to this purist mentality that when the light enters into the chapel there becomes this washed out, ethereal atmosphere.  The effect of the light evokes expressive and emotional qualities that create heightened sensations in tune with the religious activities [http://www.archdaily.com/84988/ad-classics-ronchamp-le-corbusier/]." He does this with his innovative take of the traditional stained glass windows that can be seen below.

http://www.archdaily.com/84988/ad-classics-ronchamp-le-corbusier/
A quick look at the section reveals the more fluid, structural and sculptural forms of the Chapel itself (see below).

http://www.archdaily.com/84988/ad-classics-ronchamp-le-corbusier/
 However, a panned-out view of the interior from the same orientation reveals a much different interior space (see below). To me, this is a great example of how a 2D rendering is much different than the rendering of the full space.

http://www.archdaily.com/84988/ad-classics-ronchamp-le-corbusier/
There are several things from this particular site that I feel I can take from Le Corbusier's work. The first is the power of exploration and the challenge of thinking outside of the (Catholic Cathedral) box. Another is that sculptural forms can be adapted for architectural spaces, and in some cases define architectural spaces. This is particularly key for me with my background in sculpture. Light as a formal element is also key here, remembering that small gestures can have huge impact. And finally, I think that this chapel is an excellent example of how designers and architects should think beyond plan and section renderings when envisioning a space, because this is clearly one of those spaces that moves beyond two-dimensional renderings for understanding.

[BP12] good design for all: everything fits in the fit

http://automobiles.honda.com/fit/exterior-photos.aspx
Perhaps I am a bit biased, as my Honda Fit gets me to school and back everyday from Winston, but I consider my Fit a contender for "good design for all." Compact with a tight turning radius, the fit comfortably seats four (or five if the backseat passengers are smaller in size like myself) with room to spare in the back for all necessary weekend luggage. The back seats lie flat and have successfully housed all sorts of combinations of bookcases, desks, large pieces of furniture, two bicycles, moving boxes, a cat and two dogs, or enough beach camping equipment for a week. With super stellar crash safety ratings, excellent gas mileage as a low emissions vehicle, a great sound system, and amazing affordability, I have highly recommended this car to a whole range of friends who are on the market for their next car. Incorporating both form and function, in addition to commodity, firmness and delight, I consider my compact vehicle super-sized in good design for all.

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Reverberations: Unit Summary 2


http://www.dartmouth.edu/~classics/rome2003/updates/week7_8/1113vic35Web.JPG
The middle chunk of the semester focused on the reverberations in the design world after the rules were finally written down for architecture. In the East, the rules were established and afterwards a continuation of the same principles was encouraged. In the West, a new cycle was created between classical revivals and the subsequent breaking of the rules. Each cycle was discussed in a two-week section.

We began this unit looking at Medieval churches and then contrasting those churches with Gothic cathedrals and architecture and the exploration of architecture as frozen music. The keywords we created as we considered music and design included structure, order, repetition, rhythm, contrast, balance and unity. Using these forms we then moved onto the Renaissance, where the Gothic forms were rejected and the rules of good architecture were written down. Some of the rules included reviving the past using classical language, strive for order and harmony in all things, man is at the center, move forward the secular agenda along with the religious agenda, and expand your physical world. At the same time we looked at the rules set in place in the East, of which the major difference included maintaining continuity in the past and placing community needs before the individual while exploring the inner world.  Andrea Palladio’s Villa Rotunda (image at the beginning of this entry) and his book on architectural rules was a key concept during this introduction to the unit, as his work reverberates throughout the centuries.

Once the rules were established, the Baroque period was ushered in where the rules were challenged. An example of this is Boromini’s San Carlo alle Quattro Fontane, with its undulating façade and oval shaped interior and dome, which was in direct contrast to the more classical geometric forms from the Renaissance.  Additionally in France, we looked at Versailles, King Louis the 14th ‘s reimagined palace outside of Paris, and how the architecture of happiness article by de Botton illuminates interior spaces in their relationship with its inhabitants.

As technology changes, there is a continuity of classical influences and a re-establishment as classicism as the true roots of desirable architecture. The best example of this is in England, which was quickly becoming the dominating world power as France heads towards its Revolution. The colonial expansion during this time period increases the influx of people and ideas and the first roots of the United States, which draws on Palladian influences. The Unit concluded with a trip to Monticello and Fallingwater.

The establishment of the “rules” of architecture in the Renaissance has reverberated through design practices in the West since. Either by borrowing from Palladian architecture or by rejecting the classical style in favor for something more organic, this Unit has helped to define just how deep the classical roots run in Western culture.  These layers of history and significance have helped me understand more fully why “traditional” or “conservative” buildings hark back to classical architectural types. Additionally, I think looking forward into the complexities of styles in the modern world, knowing the rules has helped me understand how and why modern architects pushed those rules and often broke them. I think that the Reverberations Unit has really helped me apply context to the many concepts from the previous Foundations Unit at the beginning of the semester. Additionally, I feel better suited to delve into the complexities of architectural forms spawned from the Industrial Revolution.